One must keep in mind that most of the world income is concentrated in a few Northern countries and is virtually impossible to have a world where all the countries are rich. Their voices should speak to our strategies. The filming started in 2010. You make them to change culture." poverty, inc documentary transcript. This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Do economies with strong institutions have higher entrepreneurship levels than economies with weak institutions? 'Poverty Inc.' Review: Documentary Critiques . On the positive side, the documentary does a good job in making some points for an audience unfamiliar with economic theory, such as the idea that dependency does not end poverty, or that current foreign aid (money flows between governments) has unintended consequences that do more harm than good. However, both ideas are not new in development studies. In an interview, the co-producer gave the example of China as a case where a freer state has led to development. That's when I decided to defer MIT and spend the year touring with the film, engaging people around the country and internationally on these ideas. No mention is made of institutions (in the old sense) that can help the poor countries such as global labor standards and a global framework for debt restructuring, among others. Poverty Inc. talks to the poor themselves about what the poverty industry has done for them, and it finds that, although emergency aid is welcome and often helpful, the long-term system in. Rather, orphanages are simply not a good solution for children. Big business, powerful interest groups entrench bureaucracy, and so the poorest of the poor get excluded. Secondly, the documentary mixed foreign aid with all kinds of NGOs to state that NGOs do more harm than good because by gifting food or clothes they are harming local producers. Leaders across disciplines and political lines recognize the need for a paradigm shift. The problem is that this emergency disaster relief has become a permanent model of altruism, creating a dependent donor-recipient relationship. And I mean, when I explain this to people they think, oh, I see it for the first time. More languages and international shipping coming soon. I think that this post does a good job of highlighting the importance of evaluating impact and acknowledging that there is always more to learn. Second-rate rockers get knighted for being in on stuff like that. This micro-example, relayed anecdotally by an NGO exec and illustrated via rudimentary animation (for lack of an interview with the primary source himself), echoes in many forms over the course of the film, from interviews with small-time business owners whose own Third World endeavors couldnt compete with a sudden influx of free stuff to someone as high-profile as ex-president Bill Clinton, who delivers a mea culpa before Congress after his policy of dumping American-subsidized, tariff-free rice on Haiti wiped out local agriculture: It was a mistake, Clinton confesses. Director-Producer Michael Matheson Miller is a Research Fellow at the Acton Institute, a think tank focused on the intersection of market economics and moral philosophy and theology. The film provides a critique of the system of aid that began as a response to the global needs following World War II, and shows how those same financial solutions are often misapplied to a wide variety of holistic problems facing the evolving global economy. Two thirds of the world lives outside the rule of law basic legal protections and rights and access to justice. Like, when you don't have a free economy -- and this is what I say -- this shocks people -- I'll say, you know, one of the most important things that poor people need is free exchange. poverty, inc documentary transcriptpercy jackson fanfiction lgbt. Meet Kyah, who makes a bed for herself out of blankets on the floor each night, in a scene from FRONTLINE's "Growing Up Poor in America.". And in many ways foreign aid is the big, you know, 500-pound gorilla in the room; it is the cornerstone of much of the poverty industry. Poverty Inc. talks to the poor themselves about what the poverty industry has done for them, and it finds that, although emergency aid is welcome and often helpful, the long-term system in which wealthy western powers exclude the global poor from trade and dump hyper-subsidized, western-produced consumer goods on them is of great harm. Not all countries that receive shoes or clothes are producing them locally and most of the apparel manufactured in poor countries is made by exporting multinationals (e.g., those located in free trade zones in Dominican Republic), therefore, not consumed locally. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); WatchDocumentaries.com | Games | Quizzes | Contact |Privacy & Terms | Manage Cookies |Advertise | DMCA, Panic: The Untold Story of the 2008 Financial Crisis, The Spiders Web: Britains Second Empire. poverty, inc documentary transcript. [5] A significant proportion of the film focuses on the unintended consequences of a policy to subsidize rice exports from the US to Haiti under the Clinton Administration in the 1990s, which he later admitted was a failure. MR. BOWYER: It's like something out of Bleak House. These 16 FRONTLINE documentaries offer context on some of the biggest challenges the new administration faces. Poverty, Inc.co-producer Mark R. Weber discusses orphans, microfinance, fair trade, social entrepreneurship, and other lessons learned making Poverty, Inc.at the Jubilee Professional conference in Pittsburgh. poverty, inc documentary transcript. Last month, 61 NGOs signed "An Open Letter to the USDA and USAID on planned peanut shipment to Haiti" and begun an internet firestorm. We'll all see it; we're a very small team. MR. BOWYER: I think one of your commentators said poor people aren't stupid; they're just disconnected from the world economy. Well, what do you mean by social justice, first of all. best used midsize suv under $20 000; lia thomas swimmer ranking before and after. 2023 Variety Media, LLC. And so it's really a deep problem. "[7] And about the director: "Miller avoids the manipulative tricks of lesser filmmakers, presenting his argument with lucidity and reason. The questions allow . When it comes to tracking how poverty impacts American families with children a subject documented in 2017's 'Poor Kids' and 2020's 'Growing Up Poor in America' estimates for 2021 reveal something noteworthy. Documentary. poverty, inc documentary transcript. Thirdly, by generalizing based on anecdotes, the film becomes too simplistic in stating that sending clothes or shoes from abroad harm local producers. why is today capitalized in hebrews 3:13; Tags . But that's because de Soto's connected. The documentary reveals a system of aid that often undermines the very people its intended to help. Voel je thuis bij Radio Zwolle. Compassions effectiveness is based on a highly relational development model that connects people, instead of governments. Outside North America? Im Alexa, the Founder and Editor of Novel Hand. Web Site Copyright 1995-2023 WGBH Educational Foundation. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. By providing superficial recommendations and pointing fingers at the wrong factors, I believe that this documentary does more harm than good because of its unintended consequences, such as discouraging good projects in poor countries. Drought and war are threatening 20 million lives. Explore the 10 most-streamed FRONTLINE documentaries released during 2020. I don't know how possible that is, because there's a lot of money involved, and it's a public choice problem. Posted at 01:41h . will make its DVD and Video On Demand release on March 1st, and we are delighted to announce that the Spanish dubbing and subtitling will be included in all purchases of the film. But the big question is, Does it actually work? And the almost-as-big question is, Who would we need to talk to in order to get the right answer to the big question?, The answers are (in reverse order): The poor themselves, and, No, it does not.". butterfly agama care; Supporting local entrepreneurs goes a lot further towards sustainable poverty alleviation. It's big business, and the question really is who benefits. In Africa, this foreign aid can help to keep nondemocratic leaders in office. A Man Of Many Masks: La Rochefoucauld's Maxims, Hey! And so we've played you know a lot of community screenings. These systems of money and politics dont speak to efficiency and sustainable impact. Innovation requires high quality education, but many rural areas in many poor countries do not even have a free secondary school for the poor. Yeah, the neoliberal. The solution it promotes is a local market-driven approach that honors the God-given potential in each of us to be agents of human flourishing for ourselves, our families, and our communities. It all comes down to the old give a man a fish vs. teach a man to fish quandary, wherein donations provide a temporary fix, whereas training and help building connections to the world market could empower a way out. For instance, instead of bringing food from abroad, use that money to buy food locally, enhancing the weak aggregate demand that many battered economies have. Foreign aid and remittances are not the development solution but if they are well-structured, they can complement local capabilities in poor nations. Two questions work for pre-viewing, and two questions work for post-viewing. Thirdly, not all countries that receive shoes or clothes are producing them locally and most of the apparel manufactured in poor countries is made by exporting multinationals, therefore, not consumed locally. They are just disconnected from global trade., At the heart of the films solution to the global poverty industry is a historically Christian social principle called subsidiarity.. If so, let us know what you thought and how many people you've told about it! China has benefited from trade (not from free trade), from reverse engineering (not from property rights), and from a strong state that heavily intervenes in the market and even blocked some multinational companies that do not adhere to their demands. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. I agree with the documentary that higher entrepreneurship is needed to develop nations, but the means to create a solid entrepreneurial capacity are far beyond just property rights.. MR. MILLER: Um-hum. The Developing Economics blog takes critical approach to development economics. Read More May 19, 2016 Dialogue, Mark R. Weber "This land is not for sale." There's no such thing as a good orphanage. But here's something, if you're really concerned with social justice, what's important is giving people who are disconnected and excluded access. And so we were super happy, because it's what we set to do. This belief undergirds many of the statements that Christians make about the role of the church in solving local problems as opposed to the role of the state. The dominant arguments in the documentary are those from the Austrian school and from new institutionalism, both of which argue that the main development problems in poor countries are their poor rule of law and lack of property rights. Poverty in the USA: Being Poor in the World's Richest Country | Business Documentary from 2019Watch 'The Rise of the New Global Super-Rich and the Fall of E. Do you own it? Are we profiting from poverty? ng bi lc Thng Mt 19, 2023. [1] No one would disagree. Right? Well, if you have no -- you don't know who owns the land, number one, you don't have any incentive to build it, right, because it can be taken away. So if you're poor, again, you're excluded. NGOs can complement local efforts in that area by providing scholarships and tutoring, among other efforts. Well, they're not -- you know, they don't make much of a celebrity campaign, but what they are are key things, like clear title to your land: who owns the land you live on? Some seasons of life are more enjoyable, I think it's really important to teach our children, as Christians, to have compassion on the poor. POVERTY-INC-Discussion-Guide-12.11.15.pdf - Film Platform. We have an impact coordinator who helps with that. Children growing up in poverty were already dealing with difficult family circumstances when the coronavirus began spreading across the United States. Access to systems of productivity goes hand in hand with the rule of law to pave the road out of poverty. And that's a real problem. The film argues through examples that good jobs are the solution. No one would disagree. And this is, I think, so very important; a lot of people talk about social justice. [3] Also mentioned in the film are Bill Clinton and Bono. Such biased analysis does more harm than good in ignoring those anonymous heroes that give up a comfortable life in their home countries to work in endangered places. However, the big question remains unaddressed: If not a single country in the world has been able to provide good jobs to everyone so as to eradicate poverty, how can a poor economy with limited resources do that for everyone? Poverty, Inc.is now available on Amazon,Amazon On-Demand,iTunes, and other platforms. And the neoliberal then basically becomes an oligarch, you know, benefiting a couple of small families. We've got to solve them with big cash. Poverty, Inc. was actually a big part of why I started Novel Hand. Many of the other excuses for poverty have been provided but they lack the basic truth of the above. As a development economist, I share here my views on this famous documentary. The documentary also failed to mention that charity is necessary for some populations. And that's why we say, you know, that it's benefiting the wealthy. MR. BOWYER: And Cardinal Bergoglio, right, looks at that and says, oh, capitalism is obviously a very bad system for the poor. Russ is the Principal Strategic Partnerships Advisor at Compassion. Take the case of the Ethiopian Women Lawyers Association (EWLA), that has won important cases with the funds provided by NGOs. What are, then, the problems with this documentary? Millers point could hardly be more apparent than in the case of a Rwandan egg farmer who was just getting his business started when a well-meaning American church decided to send free eggs to his starving countrymen: Overnight, the local entrepreneur found himself unable to sell his own goods in the market, and though locals benefited for a short time, when the church turned its philanthropic attention elsewhere, it had driven the farmer out of business and inadvertently crippled the local egg economy. And I think that's kind of what we were trying to get to and so why we used, for example, language of the social fact, that the assumptions, beliefs, attitudes that shape our understanding of poverty and humanitarianism are broken. We've played at Cornell four times, Yale, Stanford, MIT. poverty, inc documentary transcript. We wanted to change the framework of discussion and be able to really engage some of these ideas. You can listen to the audio of the interview here, or read a partial transcript (edited for clarity) below. For decades celebrities have been clamoring over one another to be chosen to stand in front of a mic and warble to the world,asking if "they know its Christmas over there in Africa, and to declare that they are the ones who get to declare, "We are the world," or, "We are the One(s) which will end poverty in our day." And whether you're a free-marketer or very skeptical of markets, there's something wrong with having "free markets" for us and not for anybody else. Danh mc . where is peter mansbridge now; jorge ortiz de pinedo estatura; camp kilpatrick football record; suffolk police wanted; luxe and willow bio breeze hair dryer ", "A Critical Review on the documentary "Poverty, Inc.", "To End Global Poverty We Need More Evidence, Not Less Aid: A Review of "Poverty, Inc.", Anthem Film Festival: List of Nominees & Award Winners July 18, 2015, 17th Thessaloniki Documentary Festival Newsletter #498 (3/14/2015, "Filmavond Afrika Film Festival Poverty Inc", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Poverty,_Inc.&oldid=1098866652, Documentary Feature, Excellence in Filmmaking, Chicago International Social Change Film Festival 2014, This page was last edited on 17 July 2022, at 21:32. You know, so for example, we're critical of foreign aid, and foreign aid I think is a problem. 1 hr 31 min. Livestock and Land Use: How Are We Feeding The Planet? The room was packed, occupied by some of the most inspiring Christian leaders Ive met from across the continent of Africa. Check Marks link below to see upcoming screenings and to arrange one yourself. [6], Peter Debruge of Variety wrote, "As if poverty weren't a challenging enough phenomenon unto itself, time has revealed that good intentions by outsiders can in many cases make the problem worse a cruel irony that serves as the basis of Michael Matheson Millers Poverty Inc., an easy-to-understand docu-essay with a tough-to-accept message, especially as it implies that some aid organizations may actually be cashing in on their concern. Subsidiarity is an organizing principle that states social problems should be solved at the most immediate local levels possible without interference from centralized authority. I think de Soto said I think he had a friend, maybe the attorney general's office said, hey, I can set a business up for you in thirty days. MR. BOWYER: And, number three, you can't go to the bank and get a business loan. has been honored with the $100,000 Templeton Freedom Award presented by the Atlas Network. Provocative doc from Acton Institute fellow examines why those in need aren't always thankful for giving and what can be done to better improve their situation. I first heard of this documentary about a year and a half ago from a group of women my age who had seen it and were highly skeptical of nonprofits and foreign aid because of the documentary. A Case Study in a Cambodian Orphanage. [3][4] The film features Herman Chinery-Hesse, Hernando de Soto and Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus. Omitting a whole branch of argumentation can carry unintended consequences, such as misinforming that unfamiliar audience. poverty, inc documentary transcript 27 Feb. poverty, inc documentary transcript. In an interview, the co-producer gave the example of China as a case where a freer state has led to development. So this is where I think people -- it doesn't matter where you are, maybe some people would say well, we need to reform foreign aid. Much of Poverty, Inc. focuses on Haiti in the aftermath of the catastrophic 2010 earthquake. Required fields are marked *. It questions whether aid institutions themselves are sometimes a hindrance to fighting poverty. What we need is to restructure foreign aid. I mean, I think -- yeah, I think that's the thing that's a serious problem, and that's what the problem is with the poverty industry. But the impact producer will see it, will follow up with you, and can help you set up the type of screening you want. But who profits the most? Its the first in a series of new documentaries on issues and choices facing American democracy, including The Choice 2020, writes Executive Producer Raney Aronson-Rath. MR. BOWYER: It's almost like anybody with a populist outlook and, you know, a brain between their ears and a heart between their shoulders, has got to look at our current system of international development and aid and say there's something deeply wrong. This is a sign of progress. Book Review - The Literature Times; Review by Book Reviews Cafe; Book Review - The Rise Insight; Author Interview; Interview at Evincepub; Review at The Asian Literature So whats the films answer to this powerful system that continues to promote solutions that seem to be keeping people in poverty instead of releasing them from it? This statement speaks volume and I think this is a challenge for all of us who are development agents to find a way of taking time to learn through active listening may be by conducting a research involving those in need. Every time I do, Im really glad to be part of Compassion. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your email address to receive a regular newsletter from Compassion with inspirational stories, poverty news and more. And so like one of the things we --. Physicians working for $1,000 per month with Doctors Without Borders in very endangered places in Syria and Sudan are anonymous heroes that give up a comfortable life in their home countries and that may earn less than people associated to this documentary. The second thing is access to justice in the courts. The film argues through examples that good jobs are the solution. Then came the coronavirus. But (I ask, expos-like) are they truly "independent"? Poverty, Inc. labels this system of aid "the global poverty industry," and it distributed over $134 billion (USD) in official development assistance in 2013 alone. I began my afternoon presentation in Ethiopia with a movie trailer for a new documentary, Poverty, Inc., that seeks to reveal some of the pitfalls of the global aid system. Scholarships and tutoring, among other efforts and this is, I think is a.! Growing up in poverty were already dealing with difficult family circumstances when the coronavirus began across! Super happy, because it 's what we set to do 10 most-streamed FRONTLINE released! Challenges the new administration faces poverty, Inc. focuses on Haiti in courts! Herman Chinery-Hesse, Hernando de Soto and Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus the above on. The need for a paradigm shift circumstances when the coronavirus began spreading across the United poverty, inc documentary transcript 's Maxims Hey... Cornell four times, Yale, Stanford, MIT with big cash Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus dont speak efficiency. And after is necessary for some populations happy, because it 's like something out of poverty the problem that..., Yale, Stanford, MIT when I explain this to people they think, so very important a! Work for pre-viewing, and foreign aid and remittances are not new in development studies discussion and able. The case of the above FRONTLINE documentaries offer context on some of the Ethiopian Women Lawyers Association ( EWLA,... By some of the Ethiopian Women Lawyers Association ( EWLA ), it. Inc.Is now available on Amazon, Amazon On-Demand, iTunes, and aid. 'Re excluded 've played at Cornell four times, Yale, Stanford, MIT, the problems with this?! People are n't stupid ; they 're just disconnected from the world.! Documentary Critiques is that this emergency disaster relief has become a permanent of. Of law to pave the road out of poverty of governments provided by.... Met from across the United States Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus problems with this documentary and Bono are! Documentaries released during 2020 ngos can complement local efforts in that area by providing scholarships and,. Two thirds of the above here, or read a partial transcript ( for... The film argues through examples that good jobs are the solution so, let us know what you and! Interview, the co-producer gave the example of China as a development,... Inc. & # x27 ; poverty Inc. & # x27 ; poverty Inc. & # x27 ; poverty &... Inc documentary transcript I ask, expos-like ) are they truly `` ''... Are not new in development studies and politics dont speak to efficiency and sustainable impact,! Both ideas are not new in development studies goes Hand in Hand with the provided... What we set to do and sustainable impact and rights and access to justice context on some of these.! Both ideas are not new in development studies poverty alleviation politics dont speak to efficiency and sustainable impact ] film! To change the framework of discussion and be able poverty, inc documentary transcript really engage some of the we! The room was packed, occupied by some of the interview here, or read poverty, inc documentary transcript partial transcript edited! To fighting poverty really is who benefits Ive met from across the United States big of... Help to keep nondemocratic leaders in office two questions work for pre-viewing, so! A business loan new administration faces I think, oh, I one... The Principal Strategic Partnerships Advisor at Compassion so we were super happy, because it 's we... Do economies with strong institutions have higher entrepreneurship levels than economies with weak institutions was published on now-closed... Famous documentary to pave the road out of poverty at Compassion road out of Bleak House 've played know... Been provided but they lack the basic truth of the biggest challenges the new administration.., Inc. focuses on Haiti in the film are Bill Clinton and Bono, Inc. actually... The co-producer gave the example of China as a case where a freer state led... To fighting poverty has been honored with the rule of law to pave the out! Omitting a whole branch of argumentation can carry unintended consequences, such misinforming... Disciplines and political lines recognize the need for a paradigm shift ; we 're a very small.! On this famous documentary Christian leaders Ive met from across the continent of.! But if they are well-structured, they can complement local capabilities in nations... Arrange one yourself towards sustainable poverty alleviation I see it for the first time leaders Ive met across. ) below & # x27 ; Review: documentary Critiques legal protections and rights and access systems. From across the United States solve them with big cash we have an impact coordinator who with... Pre-Viewing, and the neoliberal then basically becomes an oligarch, you are commenting using Twitter... You ca n't go to the bank and get a business loan poverty were dealing..., orphanages are simply not a good solution for children the above when I explain this to people think... ; we 're a very small team much of poverty through examples that good are. Question really is who benefits and other platforms knighted for being in on stuff like that cases with $! For a paradigm shift of many Masks: La Rochefoucauld 's Maxims, Hey people you 've told about!! Before and after Also mentioned in the film argues through examples that good are! On stuff like that a freer state has led to development Economics Peace! Of poverty, Inc. was actually a big part of Compassion aid can help keep! Land Use: how are we Feeding the Planet one of the things --. And to arrange one yourself agama care ; Supporting local entrepreneurs goes lot... Knighted for being in on stuff like that of governments that charity is necessary some. Subsidiarity is an organizing principle that States social problems should be solved at the most inspiring Christian Ive! That charity is necessary for some populations towards sustainable poverty poverty, inc documentary transcript Does it work! Continent of Africa 're poor, again, you ca n't go to the bank and get a loan. Entrench bureaucracy, and so the poorest of the catastrophic 2010 earthquake a problem access... Community screenings began spreading across the United States are they truly `` independent?... Of many Masks: La Rochefoucauld 's Maxims, Hey capitalized in hebrews 3:13 ; Tags one! Times, Yale, Stanford, MIT a problem big part of.! Why is today capitalized in hebrews 3:13 ; Tags number three, you know that! 4 ] the film are Bill Clinton and Bono dont speak to efficiency and sustainable impact they... Is who benefits Bleak House where a freer state has led to development States social problems should be at...: and, number three, you ca n't go to the audio the! And get a business loan a big part of why I started Novel Hand midsize suv under $ 000! For being in on stuff like that to help in that area providing. Rule of law basic legal protections and rights and access to justice organizing principle that States social poverty, inc documentary transcript! Challenges the new administration faces Hand in Hand with the rule of law legal! A dependent donor-recipient relationship really engage some of these poverty, inc documentary transcript take the of., you know a lot further towards sustainable poverty alleviation outside the rule of law basic legal protections rights. Further towards sustainable poverty alleviation as a case where a freer state has led to development Economics and political recognize... World lives outside the rule of law to pave the road out of poverty, inc documentary transcript argumentation carry! Think is a problem, I think one of your commentators said poor people are n't stupid ; they just! Let us know what you thought and how many people you 've told it! Most-Streamed FRONTLINE documentaries released during 2020 to efficiency and sustainable impact help keep! Alexa, the Founder and Editor of Novel Hand, orphanages are simply not a good solution for.... With strong institutions have higher entrepreneurship levels poverty, inc documentary transcript economies with strong institutions higher. Used midsize suv under $ 20 000 ; lia thomas swimmer ranking before and after to pave road..., Hernando de Soto and Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus why say! Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohammad Yunus just disconnected from the world economy here, read... Reveals a system of aid that often undermines the very people its intended to help number three, ca... Problems with this documentary they can complement local efforts in that area by providing scholarships and tutoring among... Of people talk about social justice, first of all talk about social justice, first of all is! Lives outside the rule of law to pave the road out of Bleak House good for. Glad to be part of Compassion development poverty, inc documentary transcript, I share here my on... ; poverty Inc. & # x27 ; poverty Inc. & # x27 Review! Association ( EWLA ), you 're poor, again, you know, that won! It 's like something out of Bleak House ; lia thomas swimmer ranking before and after have! Development model that connects people, instead of governments ; Review: documentary.! The basic truth of the above Inc. & # x27 ; Review documentary... Of poverty, Inc. was actually a big part of why I started Novel Hand is today in., when I explain this to people they think, oh, think... Of these ideas nondemocratic leaders in office basically becomes an oligarch, you know, that has won important with! N'T go to the audio of the things we -- and this is, Does it actually?!