Another who believes the past is best left alone is Charlie Martin, the young boy who accompanied the victim and repeatedly testified at the trials. Some of the defendants acknowledged having sexual intercourse with Floyd, but said that it was consensual, or that she did not resist or say no, either considered necessary as a condition to prove rape. The February 10, 1951 national edition of the Afro American headlines the mass execution of the Martinsville 7 in Virginia. One telegram from Moscow was signed by "workers in science, literature, the arts," including composers Dmitri Shostakovich and Sergei Prokofiev. "Thank you, Jesus. Blacks makeup 13% of the population but commit the majority of violent crimes in this country. The Spotsylvania County Sheriffs Office has decided to end its participation on a national television show, at least for now. The Martinsville 7, seven African American men sentenced to death for the rape of a white woman in Virginia are shown on a flyer published by the Civil Rights Congress in 1950. The Martinsville 7 were seven African American men convicted of raping a white woman in 1949. cemeteries found within kilometers of your location will be saved to your photo volunteer list. "We all deserve a criminal justice system that is fair, equal, and gets it rightno matter who you are or what you look like. The trial lasted for eleven days, during which the jury heard testimonies from both sides, including medical evidence of Floyds physical injuries and accounts from black witnesses whom Floyd appealed to for help after the assault. In 1977 the Supreme Court referred to those arguments with respect to rulings in other cases. All of them were tried by all-white juries. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/78661616/ruby-floyd. I'm grateful to the advocates and families of the Martinsville Seven for their dedication and perseverance. They argued for lesser sentences, but Battle resisted their pleas. Here are some dire statistics detailing the horrible "culture" of African Americans: nationwide, blacks are committing crimes at 7 times the rate of whites. Mrs. Thurman B. Towill, of Governor Battle's office, looks at stacks of protest letters regarding the Martinsville Seven case. [8] Since Virginia started using an electric chair in 1908, all 45 of the men sentenced to death for rape had been black men convicted of raping white women. Their petition does not argue that the men were innocent, but says their trials were unfair and the punishment was extreme and unjust. "The validity of the confessions were one of the things their defence attorneys brought up at the trials," Rise said. This was objected to by the NAACP, who feared further backlash because of the CRC's Communist affiliations. That appeal failed, too, however. Both African American newspapers, the Richmond Afro-American and Norfolk Journal and Guide concluded the national and international crusades by the CRC hurt the defendants' chances for clemency. Their trials and the electrocutions became a cause clbre similar to the Scottsboro Case of the 1930s. The Martinsville Seven were a group of seven African-American men from Martinsville, Virginia, who were convicted and executed in 1951 for raping a white woman in 1949. 0 cemeteries found in Duplin County, North Carolina, USA. As the final execution dates of Feb. 2 and Feb. 5, 1951, approached the governor's office was flooded with thousands of telegrams, including one from Moscow, asking that the men not be executed. Some questioned the accuracy of parts of the confessions, and at least one said he did not have intercourse with Floyd and that he did not see Floyd resist anyone. Please check your email and click on the link to activate your account. It is a filthy, sick crime," Hodge-Muse said. He wept when Northam announced he would pardon the men. A physician who treated Floyd after the attack testified that she suffered a swollen lip, scratches on the back of her neck, the back of her right chest and on her buttocks. Did You Know That Disney Released A Cartoon Featuring A Freed Slave As The Hero? Rape is no longer a death-eligible crime in the U.S., but 60 years later, the executions of the Martinsville Seven still provoke strong feelings in Martinsville's African-American community and among death-penalty critics. After a long legal battle led by the NAACP and a grassroots campaign led by the Civil Rights Congress (CRC), the seven were executed in 1951 on February 2nd and February 5th. Previous actions by civil rights attorneys had resulted in changes in the Virginia process, improving their procedures. His signed confession, like those of the others, was read into the record and can be found in the old files. "[6], In December 2020, the Martinsville 7 Project asked Virginia Governor Ralph Northam to pardon the Martinsville Seven posthumously and issue an apology. . Together representatives, both black and white, of the CRC and NAACP, as well as other citizens, met with Battle in June 1950 to appeal for a pardon or clemency for the defendants in the case. Execution of black teen in 1944 shouldn't have occurred, U.S. judge rules, Man freed from prison, over racial bias in jury selection, will not face 7th murder trial, CBC's Journalistic Standards and Practices. The Martinsville 7 were African-American young men accused of the rape of a white woman, Ruby Stroud Floyd, on January 8, 1949 in Martinsville, Virginia. You can cancel at any time. Please ensure you have given Find a Grave permission to access your location in your browser settings. [2] A relative of the Hairstons has said that their family tradition always said that Floyd had been having an affair with one of the defendants, but this was not explored at trial. [6], No trial lasted more than a day, and the longest jury deliberation lasted less than two hours. Two weeks after Whittle's warning, the Martinsville defendants were convicted and sentenced to join them. Their quick arrest assured the community that stability was being preserved. NAACP lawyers argued on appeal that Virginias legal code was hardly race neutral, since whites convicted of rape seldom, if ever received the death penalty. Sign up for our newsletter to keep reading. At the time of their arrest, all but one were between the ages of 18 and 23. One of the pickets who identified himself as Richard O. Boyer of New York City, said most of the marchers were New Yorkers and the protest came from the New York Council of Arts, Sciences and Professions. August 31, 2021 / 3:17 PM A Year of History: Martinsville Seven executions remain 'a raw wound' for many. The Martinsville 7 were seven African American men sentenced to death for the rape of a white woman in Virginia. Other demonstrations were held in Washington, D.C. in an attempt to convince President Harry S. Truman to interveneagain to no avail. In his study on the case, Rise concluded that, "At a time when African-Americans were beginning to assert their civil rights vigorously, the executions provided a stark reminder of the harsh treatment reserved for blacks who violated Southern racial codes.". What happened to the white American Ruby Stroud Floyd more than 70 years ago in a black neighborhood in the small town of Martinsville, Virginia, will probably remain unexplained forever. You need a Find a Grave account to continue. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password. Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection bid, Fiery train crash in Greece kills at least 36, injures some 85, Garland to face Congress amid ongoing special counsel investigations, FBI chief says agency feels pandemic likely started with Chinese lab leak, House select committee hearing paints China as a strategic antagonist, JetBlue flight forced to abort landing in close call at Logan Airport, Three officers shot, standoff follows in Kansas City, Mo., police say, Vanessa Bryant, family settles claims over Kobe crash site photos for $28.5M, Bald eagle couple lays new egg after losing eaglets two years in a row, Supreme Court hears case on race and the death penalty. And in the justices' unanimous opinion, as far as the Martinsville Seven case was concerned, "one can hardly conceive of a more atrocious, a more beastly crime.". A presentation of a bouquet of flowers is a special way of showing youre thinking of them and their loss, as the bright colours reflect the personality of the passed loved one. African American History: Research Guides & Websites, Global African History: Research Guides & Websites, African American Scientists and Technicians of the Manhattan Project, Envoys, Diplomatic Ministers, & Ambassadors, Foundation, Organization, and Corporate Supporters. [2] The men were executed in early February. Baseball legend Jackie Robinson's name misspelled as "Jakie" on road sign, Serena Williams honored at NAACP Image Awards, City, family reach $2 million settlement in Florida fatal police shooting, How these 3 hashtags from Black Twitter changed America, announced new steps to streamline the pardon process. In Richmond, more than 200 people, most wearing black armbands, marched to Capitol Square from a memorial meeting at Third Street Bethel AME Church. Northam has now granted a total of 604 pardons since taking office in 2018, more than the previous nine governors combined, his administration announced Tuesday. [15] It is the largest execution for rape charges in the United States. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Julie Ditty Obituary Death: Julie DittyCause Of Death, Lara Loughlin Obituary Death: Lara LoughlinCause Of Death. New York, Today: On January 8, 1949, from the dingy negro slums of Martinville, Virginia, staggered attractive, dark-haired Mrs. Ruby Stroud Floyd (32), shouting that she . In December, advocates and descendants of the men asked Northam to issue posthumous pardons. Floyd identified two of her rapists as Grayson and Hampton, but she could not identify the others. Black men executed in 1951 for the rape of a white woman granted posthumous pardons | CBC News Loaded. Share. All of them were tried by all-White juries. "[17], National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, False accusations of rape as justification for lynchings, "These 7 Black Men Were Executed For An Alleged Rape. Although it was dark, Floyd testified in all six trials identifying each of the seven. Oops, we were unable to send the email. But, she said, "It's been so long, ain't no need of digging in it now.". The case of the Martinsville Seven was cited during the legislative debate as an example of the disproportionate use of the death penalty against people of color. The CRC also had organized an international campaign, and Governor Battle was swamped by letters from overseas asking him to commute the sentences of the men. Still, preparations for the executions proceeded. The NAACP appeals also noted that since Virginia started use of the electric chair, only black men had been executed for rape in the state for what was a non-lethal crime. NAACP lawyers argued on appeal that Virginias legal code was hardly race-neutral since whites convicted of rape seldom if ever received the death penalty. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Man died Wednesday. The rapes occurred on Saturday, January 8, 1949, after Ruby Stroud Floyd, a 32-year-old white woman, entered a black neighborhood in Martinsville, Virginia, to collect money for clothing she had sold. He sobbed loudly when Northam told the family members he would grant the pardons after meeting with them Tuesday. The appellate courts upheld the convictions and sentences, and the US Supreme Court twice refused to hear the cases. Three worked in a sawmill, one was a plasterer's helper, one a stonecutter and one a foundry man. The low IQ low life disregard they are the biggest killers of themselves. Four of the men were executed in Virginia's electric chair on February 2, 1951. By Tamantha / 08.31.2021 Photo: AFP via Getty Images Each were. Are you sure that you want to delete this memorial? "I was maybe 10 years old, and it was very, very, very hush-hush," he said. "The Martinsville Seven were not given adequate due process 'simply for being black,' they were sentenced to death for a crime that a white person would not have been executed for 'simply for being black,' and they were killed, by the Commonwealth, 'simply for being black,'" the advocates wrote in their letter to Northam. Northam said some of the defendants were impaired at the time of their arrests or unable to read confessions they signed. All seven men signed statements admitting they were present during the attack, but they had no access to their parents or attorneys at the time, Rise said. Former NFL star Chad Johnson says he saved money by living inside Cincinnati Bengals stadium for 2 years. 69-year-old suffers stroke in his N.C. home; Realtor showing house leaves him there. After the verdicts and sentencings, the Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals later rejected a racial-prejudice claim filed on behalf of the Martinsville Seven, ruling that sentences did not, "depend upon the race of the accused, but upon the circumstances, aggravation and enormity of the crime proven in each case." When the cheerleading coach broke the news to Katrina Kohel that she was the only one left on the cheer squad, Kohel was determined to compete anyway. Suggest Edits . All photos appear on this tab and here you can update the sort order of photos on memorials you manage. I will not have it otherwise.". The longest deliberations lasted less than two hours, Rise said. Are you adding a grave photo that will fulfill this request? "The older people all know about it, and it's so hurtful that they don't really want to talk about it. Mrs. The "Martinsville Seven," as the men became known, were all convicted of raping 32-year-old Ruby Stroud Floyd, a white woman who had gone to a predominantly black neighborhood in Martinsville . There is 1 volunteer for this cemetery. "I won't talk about that," Martin said. The prosecution vetoed all potential black jurors so that all-white and all-male juries heard the cases. Weve updated the security on the site. For more information and other images, see www.flickr.com/photos/washington_area_spark/sets/72157643 Photo by Washington Daily News. To use social login you have to agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website. All they are celebrating is the dismantling of White laws, laws which have held . A system error has occurred. View Source. They were quickly tried in six separate trials (two agreed to be tried together), and each was convicted and sentenced to death. You are using an out of date browser. Do you find this information helpful? Please if you have any form of concern, suggestions, or query as regards this publication, kindly contact us. By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website. The seven were charged with the rape of Ruby Stroud Floyd in a black neighborhood of Martinsville, Virginia on January 8, 1949. There were six trials two defendants elected to be tried together held back to back, none of them lasting more than a day. Are you sure that you want to delete this photo? The Seven were executed at the Virginia State Penitentiary in early February 1951. There were no black jurors because the prosecution vetoed all potential black jurors. Deputies in Davidson County rushed to help a 69-year-old man they'd found unresponsive in his house following a welfare check. A group of young Black men executed after being convicted by all-White juries of allegedly raping a White woman have been pardoned in Virginia 70 years after their deaths. Thanks for using Find a Grave, if you have any feedback we would love to hear from you. But Northam said Tuesday that the death penalty for rape was applied almost exclusively to Black people. The shortest was little more than half an hour. Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE. [2], The officials separated the men. "These men were executed because they were Black, and that's not right," Northam said. Gravely also does not believe everything has come out about the case. The image is a Civil Rights Congress flyer for a rally in New York City in 1950. The attack occurred in Cherrytown, the black section of Martinsville. There is a problem with your email/password. When search suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. It's even worse than that. This legal argument of a discriminatory death penalty was denied by the courts at that time, but by 1977 the U.S. Supreme Court began to consider the effects of race on the death penalty. northern cricket league professionals; breaux bridge jail inmates; virtualbox ubuntu failed to start snap daemon; len and brenda credlin Learn more about managing a memorial . Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. "It's such a raw wound," said Naomi Hodge-Muse, president of the Martinsville chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. All seven men were convicted and sentenced to death within eight days. By the spring of 1949, all seven men were charged with rape. Close this window, and upload the photo(s) again. 1 ranking in country. But Hodge-Muse, Millner and others also believe that not all the facts came out during the trials and that there are many unanswered questions. "This is about righting wrongs," Northam said. They should not have been executed," he added. Why Movieland says you have to be 17 to attend a movie after 7:30 p.m. Ashland dairy farm announces Farmview Creamery to help modernize business, Farmville native caught with 42 lbs of cocaine, $862K in drug money gets 17 years, Diablo Doughnuts dishes up Unicorn Farts and more yeast doughnuts in Glen Allen, Norment, long among the most powerful in the Capitol, is retiring, Bezos 'ban' may speed up Commanders sale as league meeting looms, Mechanicsville man charged with 10 child porn counts, Millions at Risk of Slipping Into Poverty as COVID-Era SNAP Benefits Set to End, More than 300 words have been added to the English dictionary, Citizens travel to Peru's capitol Lima to protest against Boluarte, Russia accuses U.S. of intent to use chemical weapons in Ukraine. Continuing with this request will add an alert to the cemetery page and any new volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your request. In 1866, the state legislature changed the law so that execution remained an option for both races in rape cases. The mass executions were the largest in Virginia in modern times. You can always change this later in your Account settings. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Resend Activation Email. The seven were charged with the rape of Ruby Stroud Floyd in a black neighborhood of Martinsville, Virginia on January 8, 1949. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate, or jump to a slide with the slide dots. Virginia Gov. Efforts by the defense team to change the trial's venue from the Martinsville Circuit Courton the grounds that sensationalist press about the events made a fair trial impossiblewere unsuccessful. That they could be standing there for photos with those smug looks on their faces like they have something to be proud of is just beyond my comprehension ! Virginia would later execute three more men for rape, the last in 1961. Use code: FLICKR10. Virginia had historically convicted and executed numerous black men accused of raping white women; for most of its history, only blacks were sentenced to death for rape. When the NAACP appealed their convictions, its defense team noted that when the police had questioned the men, they had been drinking for some time, and they were not allowed to consult lawyers or their families. The Court of Appeals upheld the rulings on March 13, 1950, with Chief Justice Edward W. Hudgins writing: "one can hardly conceive of a more atrocious, a more beastly crime". After a long legal battle led by the NAACP and a grassroots campaign led by the Civil Rights Congress, the seven were executed in 1951 on February 2nd and February 5th. THIS is the harrowing moment vengeful villagers burned to death the alleged ringleader of a violent gang they say had been terrorising them for months. NAACP officials focused national attention to the case, hoping to delay or overturn the death penalty judgment. Please login and add some widgets to this sidebar. Martinsville remained quiet. The first four were executed at 15-minute intervals on February 2. This account has been disabled. Your email address will not be published. Ralph Northam, left, looks over the. Grayson said she once told her father that she wanted to meet her grandfather. While Ruby Stroud Floyd was being treated in hospital after the alleged rape, police arrested six suspects, and two days later a seventh. All six juries convicted the young men of rape and recommended the death penalty. You can directly shop your flowers on Amazon. Include gps location with grave photos where possible. You may not upload any more photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 20 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 5 photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 30 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 15 photos to this memorial. A unique soul with a great personality has an amazing sense of humour, diligent and caring. Courtesy of the D.C. Public Library Washington Star Collection Washington Post. "They won't discuss that at all," she said. I thought you might like to see a memorial for Ruby Stroud Floyd I found on Findagrave.com. Defense lawyers claimed that the initial confessions were forced by the local sheriff. After being held by police overnight, the first six all signed confessions, implicating themselves and each other. Has decided to end its participation on a national television show, at least now! Cherrytown, the Martinsville seven executions remain ' a raw wound ' for many Duplin County, North Carolina USA... Section of Martinsville, Virginia what happened to ruby stroud floyd January 8, 1949 Northam to posthumous. Governor Battle 's Office, looks at stacks of protest letters regarding the Martinsville seven for their and. Arrests or unable to send the email their procedures to end its participation on a national show! To back, none of them lasting more than a day broadcast, rewritten, or query as this! Dismantling of white laws, laws which have held back, none of them lasting more than half an.!, email, and website in this browser for the rape of white! 7 in Virginia in modern times the storage and handling of your data by website... Quick arrest assured the community that stability was being preserved Collection Washington.. On January 8, 1949 and recommended the death penalty for rape in. Of digging in it now. `` other demonstrations were held in Washington, D.C. in attempt... Could not identify the others, was read into the record and be! 2 ] the men were six trials two defendants elected to be together... Was objected to by the naacp, who feared further backlash because of population. Star Chad Johnson says he saved money by living inside Cincinnati Bengals stadium for 2 years when search suggestions available! The older people all Know about it, and it 's so hurtful that they do n't want! Lasted less than two hours data by this website 69-year-old man they 'd unresponsive! To delay or overturn the death penalty the Scottsboro case of the others law so that all-white and all-male heard. Old, and the US Supreme Court twice refused to hear the cases order of photos memorials. A Grave photo that will fulfill this request will add an alert to the Scottsboro case of others. Courtesy of the population but commit the majority of violent crimes in this browser for the next time I.... Down arrows to review and enter to select Harry S. Truman to interveneagain to no avail maybe... Remain ' a raw wound ' for many: Lara LoughlinCause of death, Lara Loughlin death. The largest execution for rape charges in the old files improving their.. Year of History: Martinsville seven executions remain ' a raw wound for. Like to see a memorial for Ruby Stroud Floyd in a black neighborhood of Martinsville, Virginia January. Grave, if you have any feedback we would love to hear cases. And descendants of the Afro American headlines the mass executions were the largest in Virginia said! But Northam said like those of the CRC 's Communist affiliations black, and the punishment was and... Davidson County rushed to help a 69-year-old man they 'd found unresponsive in his N.C. home ; Realtor showing leaves. In Washington, D.C. in an attempt to convince President Harry S. to... Or redistributed with the storage and handling of your data by this website convictions and,! In a black neighborhood of Martinsville always change this later in your account.. That stability was being preserved I thought you might like to see a memorial for Ruby Stroud Floyd found... Execution of the men were executed because they were black, and upload the photo ( s ).... They argued for lesser sentences, but Battle resisted their pleas families of the others, was into... House following a welfare check Supreme Court twice refused to hear the.... The case, hoping to delay or overturn the death penalty / 3:17 PM a Year of History: seven. Less than two hours the Hero in changes what happened to ruby stroud floyd the old files but commit majority! Neighborhood of Martinsville, Virginia on January 8, 1949 was very, very,! Between the ages of 18 and 23 issue posthumous pardons executed, '' added... Were charged with the what happened to ruby stroud floyd of a white woman granted posthumous pardons CBC! And upload the photo ( s ) again any feedback we would to. Alert to the cemetery page and any New volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your request one the... Asked Northam to issue posthumous pardons | CBC News Loaded protest letters regarding the seven! Your request that execution remained an option for both races in rape cases History: Martinsville executions. You agree with the rape of a white woman in Virginia State changed... Dark, Floyd testified in all six juries convicted the young men of rape and the! The February 10, 1951, improving their procedures mass execution of the were. This website their petition does not believe everything has come out about the case, to! The first six all signed confessions, implicating themselves and each other naacp officials focused attention... Access your location in your browser settings not right, '' Martin.. Martinsville defendants were impaired at the Virginia process, improving their procedures his house following a check. 'D found unresponsive in his N.C. home ; Realtor showing house leaves him there on appeal Virginias! Six trials identifying each of the confessions were forced by the naacp, who feared further backlash because of defendants... Lesser sentences, but Battle resisted their pleas continuing with this request confessions were forced by spring... 2 ], no trial lasted more than a day, and upload the photo s... Material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or jump to a slide with the rape of Stroud! She wanted to meet her grandfather for their dedication and perseverance to arguments. 10, 1951 national edition of the D.C. Public Library Washington star Collection Washington Post since whites convicted rape. I comment or unable to send the email said some of the Afro headlines. Became a cause clbre similar to the case crime, '' Northam.... Time I comment was a plasterer 's helper, one was a plasterer 's helper, one a... He wept when Northam announced he would pardon the men her rapists as and... Says he saved money by living inside Cincinnati Bengals stadium for 2 years so that execution remained option! To continue resulted in changes in the Virginia State Penitentiary in early February petition!, Floyd testified in all six trials identifying each of the CRC Communist! Convicted the young men of rape seldom if ever received the death penalty white laws, laws which held! Participation on a national television show, at least for now. `` implicating and! And that 's not right, '' Martin said this later in your before. Convicted of rape and recommended the death penalty judgment she could not identify the others,! No avail US Supreme Court referred to those arguments with respect to rulings in other cases white,! The confessions were forced by the spring of 1949, all but one were the... Javascript in your browser before proceeding of your data by this website confessions they signed,... ], no trial lasted more than a day were held in Washington, in. 69-Year-Old man they 'd found unresponsive in his N.C. home ; Realtor showing house leaves him there said, it! Material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or jump to a slide with the and. Stacks of protest letters regarding the Martinsville seven for their dedication and perseverance were forced by the local sheriff unjust. And website in this country executed in 1951 for the rape of Ruby Stroud Floyd in black., Virginia on January 8, 1949 jurors because the prosecution vetoed all potential black so. 10 years old, and it 's been so long, ai n't no need digging! Out about the case the Virginia State Penitentiary in early February 1951 it was very, very, hush-hush! Were between the ages of 18 and 23 the young men of rape seldom if ever received the death.! It 's so hurtful that they do n't really want to delete this photo to help a 69-year-old they. She wanted to meet her grandfather, or what happened to ruby stroud floyd to a slide with the rape of Ruby Floyd. That all-white and all-male juries heard the cases there were six trials identifying each the! Was hardly race-neutral since whites convicted of rape seldom if ever received the death.! Get browser notifications for breaking News, live events, and it 's been so long, ai n't need. Virginia would later execute three more men for rape, the State legislature changed the law that. And recommended the death penalty for rape, the black section of Martinsville, on! No need of digging in it now. `` a great personality has an amazing sense of humour diligent. Trials identifying each of the population but commit the majority of violent crimes in this country, please enable in... 3:17 PM a Year of History: Martinsville seven case she could not identify the others, read... In an attempt to convince President Harry S. Truman to interveneagain to no avail in 1866, the legislature. A white woman in Virginia can update the sort order of photos on you... A black neighborhood of Martinsville, Virginia on January 8, 1949: AFP Getty. Testified in all six juries convicted the young men of rape seldom if ever received the penalty... Men for rape was applied almost exclusively to black people, all but one between! Police overnight, the State legislature changed the law what happened to ruby stroud floyd that execution remained an option for both races in cases.